Last night, I went to the midnight showing of The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (DOS), and this time, I did not make the mistake of entering the cinema with high expectations. This made it easier to cope with what I found lacking or mutilated in the film. Before we begin, I just want to say that DOS was a lot better than An Unexpected Journey. Here's why. (Contains spoilers).
In the first installment of this "Hobbit Trilogy," the focus was mainly on Thorin and Co. being chased down by the orcs, which was not enjoyable at all. Since Azog isn't in Tolkien's version, the true version, of
The Hobbit. There were more aspects of DOS that I found enjoyable, so the second was better than the first etc whatever.
For one thing, Elves. A popular race in Middle-earth (albeit not my favorite. I like the ever-underrated race of men), it was good to see them brought back in a fresh setting. We haven't seen much of the wood elves of Mirkwood, and this opened that up to everyone. The design of the kingdom was a little less festive than what I pictured in my head while reading, but it fit with the movie.
Thranduil, portrayed by Lee Pace, is the king of Mirkwood and Legolas' father. I was glad the movie did not try to make him seem evil, because he isn't. He only wants to protect his people, and Thorin is putting them in danger by going on this quest and asking for Thranduil's help. But there is an elf that does help the dwarves. That would be the captain of the guard, Tauriel.
When I first heard about the addition of this female warrior elf, I was skeptical. But I warmed up to her. Tolkien's work does tend to lack in strong female characters, and Tauriel brings that to the film with grace. I'd go as far as to say she is one of my favorite characters in the movie. The one thing that bothered me was the love triangle.
Honestly, who even
likes love triangles? DOS teeters on building one between Legolas, Tauriel, and Kili. It seems to hint that Legolas has feelings for Tauriel, Kili for Tauriel, and Tauriel for them both to some extent. This development almost subtracts from the power of Gimli's infatuation with Galadriel and her acceptance of him as a dwarf despite ages of prejudice and racism between elves and dwarves. Also, the friendship between Legolas and Gimli is supposed to be something new and unseen. Having Tauriel and Kili bond diminishes the importance of Legolas and Gimli's friendship. I mean, they sail to the Grey Havens together. That's intense commitment for a dwarf-elf friendship. However, Kili, as we know, will die in the next film, and I'd be willing to bet Tauriel does, too.
Legolas wasn't in the book, but he seems to fit in the film. I appreciate that the writers made him a racist little prince. It stresses the importance of his development throughout the LOTR trilogy. The nod at their future friendship through Leggy's insulting of Gloin's portrait of his child made me laugh and possibly wins the prize for my favorite quip.
The development they added to Bard's character was well thought-out. They built a story and emotional connection for him, strengthening his character.
Like before, I enjoyed Martin Freeman's performance as Bilbo Baggins, but he especially shines through when interacting with Smaug. The scenes inside the gloriously-designed halls of Erebor kept me all scrunched up in my seat.
Smaug himself was stunning. The visuals, the voice. It was all such an improvement from what we saw in the first trailer, which frankly had me worried. The Smaug there looked more like a mutation of Godzilla, whereas the Smaug they used in the movie had the wolfish characteristics Tolkien describes. The special effects were marvelous. All the gold and coins, and the motions of the dragon, it was truly impressive.
But there were things I found underwhelming and even disappointing in the movie. Need I mention Azog again? And the bone-crushingly annoying joke they made of Radagast? When he was described as quiet and reserved in the Silmarillion, I did not picture a madman with bird shit caked to his head.
Additionally, while the scenes in Dol Gildur were enjoyable because of the foreshadowing and threat of Sauron, they seemed lacking in suspense. Gandalf's absence needed explanation in the movie setting, but it it is approached in a disjointed way.
Most confusing of all, though, was Lake Town. Contrast it with the fading splendor of Minas Tirith or the quiet glory of Edoras, and it felt like a shard of glass among feathers. I'm guessing it was supposed to feel off, yes, but Lake Town should have felt a little more Bree-like, not like something out of Harry Potter. It was the Master's house the got to me. The lamps, the paintings, the piles of books. In Gondor we see torches, not chandeliers. I didn't want it to echo Gondor in any way, but Lake town did not feel as if it belonged in Middle-earth, or at least the Middle-earth Peter Jackson constructed in LOTR. I would expect a little bit more consistency.
While I realize
The Hobbit has a lighter feel than
The Lord of the Rings, the movies felt like they don't quite fit together. Part of that is the coloring. Parts of the movies, certain scenes, felt like an Ugg-clad teen was pasting Instagram filters over the shots. The colors seemed so unreal at some points. For example, Dol Gildur and Mirkwood were washed in surreal blue-teal-greens. It made parts of the movie cheesy. Speaking of cheesy, dare I mention Beorn? He looked like a 70s werewolf, not like something from Tolkien's Middle-earth. Not to mention the fact that his part felt rushed over.
Overall, the thing that disappointed me most was the blatant milking of a classic novel. There is no excuse for splitting The Hobbit into three films. They feel like extra weight, necessary only to make more money off the franchise. And while I do understand that business works like that, it makes me sad to see the original story force-fed with subplots. They're just cramming them down our throats at this point. It was nice to return to Middle-earth, but I can't help but feel it could have been handled in a simpler, more respectful manner.
I only hope the third movie will be better. In a way, I'm looking forward to the deaths of Fili, Kili, and Thorin. It will have an emotional pull to it. Fili and Kili were always my favorites, so hopefully it will have an impact on me.